Giants played like a 62% winner and still lost to Washington by three
The snaps favored New York by 1.6 points, but Washington's success rate, a late touchdown and four flags decided the game.


The verdict
Played like that, the Giants win 62% of the time. Instead they lost 24-21 to the Washington Commanders at home, a result that went against the snaps. It was not a robbery. A 62% game is a lean, not a lock, and the Giants gave back the margin in the fourth quarter.
The deserved margin was 1.6 points in New York's favor. The scoreboard said otherwise by three.
What the score hid
EPA, or expected points added, measures how much each snap moves the scoring outlook. The Giants averaged 0.06 per snap. Washington averaged 0.05. That is close to nothing separating them, and it is why the snaps leaned New York.
Success rate tells the other half. The Giants were successful on 46% of snaps. Washington was at 58%. The Commanders were more consistent, and the Giants made up the gap with the bigger plays.
Luck points ran against New York. The Giants finished at -0.8 and Washington at +2.9, a 3.7-point swing in Washington's favor.
The swing play came with 1:05 left in the fourth quarter. J.Daniels threw short middle to S.Diggs for a 32-yard touchdown out of a no-huddle shotgun look. It added 32 percentage points of win probability for Washington and settled the game.
The calls
Head coach John Harbaugh made one fourth-down decision that cost the Giants real value. On fourth-and-3 from Washington's 46-yard line in the fourth quarter, with 14:15 left, the Giants punted. The model said go. The punt cost 0.7 expected points, and the game ended three points apart.
He also punted on fourth-and-12 from the 42 in the first quarter, when the model preferred a field goal. That was a clear call, and it cost 0.8 expected points. The field goal try on fourth-and-4 from the 15 later in the first quarter was the right call by the model, and it missed.
The flags hurt more. With 3:27 left, a delay of game cost the Giants 4 yards and 12 points of win probability. At 1:46, defensive pass interference gave Washington 33 yards and cost another 11. A first-quarter delay of game and a false start to open the fourth added 6 and 3. Four of the biggest flags went against New York, and three came in the fourth quarter.
The trend
The record is 5-3-1. The deserved record is 5.6 wins, which puts the Giants 0.1 wins worse than the snaps say, 16th of 32 on the luck sheet. They are 4-2 in one-score games, so the close-game record has not been the problem.
The fourth-down habit is. Harbaugh's Giants have been graded on 48 fourth downs. The model recommended going on 7 of them, and the Giants went on 3. That puts the Chicken Index at 57%, and the season's fourth-down decisions have cost 7.4 expected points, including one clear miss.
Overall the Giants are a true middle team. Their net EPA per snap, offense against what they allow, is 0.001, which ranks 15th of 32. Total luck points are +0.9, so nothing about this record is borrowed. Fewer flags and a more aggressive fourth-down chart are the changes with the most room.
Next up is the Jacksonville Jaguars, at home on Sunday, Nov. 22, at 4:25 PM ET on CBS.