Most Valuable Player
MVP- 1
Brock Purdy49ers · +0.32 EPA per dropback · 2,369 pass yds, 20 TD, 5 INT · team 8-167 - 2
Joe BurrowBengals · +0.26 EPA per dropback · 2,795 pass yds, 27 TD, 6 INT · team 7-266 - 3
Trevor LawrenceJaguars · +0.28 EPA per dropback · 2,284 pass yds, 21 TD, 5 INT · team 7-264Our pick - 4
Josh AllenBills · +0.21 EPA per dropback · 2,223 pass yds, 13 TD, 7 INT · team 8-161 - 5
Jared GoffLions · +0.18 EPA per dropback · 2,437 pass yds, 18 TD, 4 INT · team 7-258 - 6
Patrick MahomesChiefs · +0.16 EPA per dropback · 2,385 pass yds, 19 TD, 4 INT · team 7-258 - 7
Caleb WilliamsBears · +0.17 EPA per dropback · 1,546 pass yds, 8 TD, 5 INT · team 7-258 - 8
Kirk CousinsVikings · +0.10 EPA per dropback · 2,547 pass yds, 22 TD, 9 INT · team 7-255
Purdy leads our ladder at 67 with +0.32 EPA per dropback (expected points added: how much a play moves the scoreboard, on average) and an 8-1 team. Burrow is one point back at 66, with the most yards (2,795) and touchdowns (27) of the six. We would vote Lawrence: +0.28 per dropback is nearly Purdy's rate, and he does it for a 7-2 Jaguars team with 21 touchdowns against 5 picks. The index cannot separate a quarterback from his supporting cast, and it only counts quarterbacks, so a non-passer never gets a look. Nine games is a small sample, and this race will flip again.
Who qualifies: Quarterbacks with at least 185 dropbacks. Our index: EPA per dropback 40%, total EPA 25%, team win rate 25%, completion over expected 10%.
Offensive Player of the Year
OPOY- 1
Jaxon Smith-NjigbaSeahawks · 1,236 scrimmage yds (29 rush, 1,207 rec) · 10 TD · +64.75 total EPA on 112 touches and targets74Our pick - 2
Jahmyr GibbsLions · 1,384 scrimmage yds (1,000 rush, 384 rec) · 13 TD · +11.52 total EPA on 253 touches and targets67 - 3
Christian McCaffrey49ers · 950 scrimmage yds (519 rush, 431 rec) · 13 TD · +30.19 total EPA on 165 touches and targets64 - 4
Ja'Marr ChaseBengals · 878 scrimmage yds (0 rush, 878 rec) · 7 TD · +47.87 total EPA on 87 touches and targets63 - 5
Christian WatsonPackers · 916 scrimmage yds (0 rush, 916 rec) · 7 TD · +39.27 total EPA on 79 touches and targets62 - 6
Kenneth Walker IIIChiefs · 1,044 scrimmage yds (872 rush, 172 rec) · 11 TD · +16.69 total EPA on 196 touches and targets62 - 7
CeeDee LambCowboys · 970 scrimmage yds (-6 rush, 976 rec) · 8 TD · +27.89 total EPA on 125 touches and targets61 - 8
Chuba HubbardPanthers · 958 scrimmage yds (711 rush, 247 rec) · 9 TD · +27.09 total EPA on 198 touches and targets61
Smith-Njigba leads by seven points over Jahmyr Gibbs, 74 to 67, and the reason is efficiency. His +64.75 total EPA on 112 touches and targets is more than double anyone else's on the list, and he has 1,207 receiving yards. Gibbs has the bigger yardage total (1,384) and 13 touchdowns, but only +11.52 EPA on 253 touches, which says volume is doing the work. McCaffrey (+30.19) is the best runner by value. Our index leans on yards and touchdowns, which flatter high-volume backs, so if anything it understates the gap.
Who qualifies: Running backs, receivers and tight ends with at least 77 touches and targets. Our index: scrimmage yards 40%, total EPA 40%, touchdowns 20%.
Defensive Player of the Year
DPOY- 1
Will Anderson Jr.Texans · 11.5 sacks · 15 TFL · 23 QB hits · 1 passes defended · 44 tackles99Our pick - 2
Greg RousseauBills · 8 sacks · 10 TFL · 27 QB hits · 8 passes defended · 25 tackles92 - 3
Andrew Van GinkelVikings · 8.5 sacks · 9 TFL · 17 QB hits · 1 INT · 1 passes defended · 28 tackles86 - 4
George KarlaftisChiefs · 5.5 sacks · 10 TFL · 21 QB hits · 1 INT · 10 passes defended · 34 tackles85 - 5
Dallas TurnerVikings · 8 sacks · 7 TFL · 22 QB hits · 3 passes defended · 27 tackles84 - 6
T.J. WattSteelers · 7.5 sacks · 9 TFL · 12 QB hits · 1 INT · 4 passes defended · 20 tackles82 - 7
David BaileyJets · 7.5 sacks · 10 TFL · 12 QB hits · 3 passes defended · 45 tackles81 - 8
Chase YoungSaints · 8 sacks · 5 TFL · 15 QB hits · 4 passes defended · 19 tackles80
Anderson sits at 99, seven points clear of Greg Rousseau at 92, and the numbers back it: 11.5 sacks and 15 tackles for loss through the season so far, both tops among the six. Rousseau is the challenger, with 27 QB hits and 8 passes defended, and he does more of the quiet work. We stay with Anderson. What our index misses is coverage and run-stopping that never become a sack or a pass breakup, and it favors edge rushers because they pile up countable plays. Anderson's one pass defended is a reminder of how narrow that profile is.
Who qualifies: Defenders who played at least 7 games. Our index: impact plays 70% (sack 2, interception 3, tackle for loss 0.7, pass defended 0.8, QB hit 0.5), sacks 30%.
Offensive Rookie of the Year
OROY- 1
Emmett JohnsonChiefs · 519 scrimmage yds (212 rush, 307 rec) · 4 TD · +18.50 total EPA on 71 touches and targets68Our pick - 2
Denzel BostonBrowns · 523 scrimmage yds (0 rush, 523 rec) · 3 TD · +8.61 total EPA on 64 touches and targets62 - 3
KC ConcepcionBrowns · 501 scrimmage yds (43 rush, 458 rec) · 2 TD · +8.22 total EPA on 74 touches and targets59 - 4
Jonah ColemanBroncos · 319 scrimmage yds (191 rush, 128 rec) · 3 TD · +5.17 total EPA on 61 touches and targets52 - 5
Jalon DanielsBuccaneers · 501 pass yds, 3 TD, 5 INT · -0.09 EPA per dropback47 - 6
Seth McGowanColts · 302 scrimmage yds (292 rush, 10 rec) · 2 TD · +0.00 total EPA on 65 touches and targets47 - 7
Kaelon Black49ers · 373 scrimmage yds (356 rush, 17 rec) · 2 TD · -6.58 total EPA on 87 touches and targets47 - 8
Makai LemonEagles · 307 scrimmage yds (-5 rush, 312 rec) · 1 TD · +4.15 total EPA on 55 touches and targets47
Johnson leads at 68, six points ahead of Denzel Boston at 62, and he gets there on value: +18.50 EPA on 71 touches, more than double Boston's +8.61 on 64. Boston has more yards (523 to 519) and is the only real receiving threat on a Browns offense that also has KC Concepcion (501 yards) splitting looks. Johnson's 4 touchdowns beat Boston's 3. The race is thin: the fifth name is a quarterback at minus 0.09 EPA per dropback. Rookie samples are small, and our index cannot see blocking or the quality of the offense around them.
Who qualifies: Rookies on offense (quarterbacks with 60+ dropbacks, others with 5 touches and targets a week). Our index: total EPA 45%, yards 35% (passing yards count 0.45), touchdowns 20%.
Defensive Rookie of the Year
DROY- 1
David BaileyJets · 7.5 sacks · 10 TFL · 12 QB hits · 3 passes defended · 45 tackles86Our pick - 2
Arvell ReeseGiants · 4.5 sacks · 8 TFL · 5 QB hits · 1 INT · 4 passes defended · 81 tackles78 - 3
Gabe JacasPatriots · 3.5 sacks · 4 TFL · 10 QB hits · 1 INT · 1 passes defended · 30 tackles67 - 4
Hezekiah MassesRaiders · 1 TFL · 1 QB hits · 3 INT · 7 passes defended · 33 tackles61 - 5
Brandon CissePackers · 1.5 sacks · 2 TFL · 2 QB hits · 1 INT · 9 passes defended · 38 tackles61 - 6
Caleb DownsCowboys · 2 sacks · 1 TFL · 3 QB hits · 1 INT · 3 passes defended · 66 tackles60 - 7
Sonny StylesCommanders · 1 sacks · 5 TFL · 2 QB hits · 1 INT · 4 passes defended · 80 tackles60 - 8
Dani Dennis-SuttonPackers · 3 sacks · 4 TFL · 7 QB hits · 2 passes defended · 26 tackles59
Bailey leads by eight, 86 to 78 over Arvell Reese, with 7.5 sacks, 10 tackles for loss and 12 QB hits for the Jets. Reese is the case for the challenger: 81 tackles, 4.5 sacks, an interception and 4 passes defended make him the more complete player for the Giants. We stay with Bailey, because disruption on early downs ends drives faster than tackles after the catch. The index rewards countable plays, so a linebacker who fills gaps and covers can be undercounted. Reese's tackle count is where that shows up. Raiders corner Hezekiah Masses, with 3 interceptions, is the lucky-bounce name to watch.
Who qualifies: Rookie defenders who played at least 60% of their team's games. Our index: impact plays 70%, sacks and interceptions 30%.
Coach of the Year
COY- 1
Andy ReidChiefs · Chiefs 7-2 · on pace for +7.2 wins over 17 games vs last season (6 wins) · +0.21 net EPA per play66 - 2
Zac TaylorBengals · Bengals 7-2 · on pace for +7.2 wins over 17 games vs last season (6 wins) · +0.15 net EPA per play65Our pick - 3
John HarbaughGiants · Giants 5-3-1 · on pace for +6.4 wins over 17 games vs last season (4 wins) · +0.02 net EPA per play61 - 4
Kyle Shanahan49ers · 49ers 8-1 · on pace for +3.1 wins over 17 games vs last season (12 wins) · +0.21 net EPA per play61 - 5
Joe BradyBills · Bills 8-1 · on pace for +3.1 wins over 17 games vs last season (12 wins) · +0.15 net EPA per play60 - 6
Dan CampbellLions · Lions 7-2 · on pace for +4.2 wins over 17 games vs last season (9 wins) · +0.07 net EPA per play60 - 7
Kevin O'ConnellVikings · Vikings 7-2 · on pace for +4.2 wins over 17 games vs last season (9 wins) · +0.03 net EPA per play59 - 8
Todd MonkenBrowns · Browns 6-4 · on pace for +5.2 wins over 17 games vs last season (5 wins) · -0.04 net EPA per play58
Andy Reid leads at 66 and Zac Taylor is one back at 65, with identical 7-2 records, identical +7.2 win-pace jumps over last season's 6 wins, and a gap only in net EPA per play: +0.21 for the Chiefs, +0.15 for the Bengals. We would vote Taylor, because the Bengals got there with a worse underlying profile and still have not lost control of the race. John Harbaugh at 5-3-1 with the Giants is the real challenger, up 6.4 wins on pace. The index rewards the jump from last year, so it punishes the 49ers and Bills for being good already, and it cannot see injuries.
Who qualifies: Head coaches of teams with four or more games played. Our index: win-pace jump over last season 60%, win rate 25%, net EPA per play 15%.
Who is leading the NFL MVP race right now?
Brock Purdy of the 49ers leads our MVP ladder at 67 through Week 11, one point ahead of Joe Burrow (66) and three ahead of Trevor Lawrence (64). It is our own index, not the official race.
Who is the favorite for Defensive Player of the Year?
Will Anderson Jr. of the Texans leads our ladder at 99, with 11.5 sacks, 15 tackles for loss and 23 QB hits. Greg Rousseau of the Bills is second at 92.
These are Pigskin Nightly's own indexes, built from this season's play-by-play and box scores with the weights written under each race, so anyone can check them. They say who is ahead today, not who will win, and they are not the official voting. See also our power rankings and how we judge football.