Pigskin Nightly
More
7 live
Latest
IND 3FinalHOU 26ARI 7Q2 4:32KC 17Win probKC 93%BAL 12Q2 10:47CAR 7Win probBAL 51%MIA 3Q2 9:44BUF 13Win probBUF 97%NO 0Q2 10:16CHI 10Win probCHI 90%TB 0Q2 5:26DET 7Win probDET 77%TEN 3Q2 12:40DAL 20Win probDAL 95%PIT 0Q2 9:23PHI 13Win probPHI 76%NYJ SunLAC JAX SunNYG LV SunDEN MIN SunSF CIN MonWSH
Giants DeskThe Lab Report

Giants spend 64% of their cap on the field and still sit 5-3-1

New York ranks 31st of 32 in value for cap spent, yet the deserved-standings and market numbers say the 5-3-1 record is about right.

MilestoneThe Lab Report5.6Deserved wins · The Lab
By Giants Desk, Pigskin NightlyNov 19, 2:00 PM ET2 min read

The most surprising number in the Giants file is 64%. That is the share of New York's $239.3 million in cap spending that is actually on the field, and it ranks 31st of 32 teams in value. The cheapest useful player on the roster is a quarterback, J.J. McCarthy, at $0.9 million.

64%: the cap is not on the field

The Giants have $65.8 million on injured reserve and another $21.5 million tied to players who are healthy but not playing. The league figure for cap spending is $314.6 million.

McCarthy has taken 34% of the snaps on a $0.9 million hit. That puts him at the 19th percentile in pay and the 84th in playing time, the biggest bargain on the team. Devin Singletary is the other end: a $2.55 million running back at the 72nd percentile in pay and the 40th in playing time.

For Sunday, it means the roster is carrying more dead weight than almost anyone, and the quarterback room is getting its production from the cheapest line on the books. Read Paid vs Played.

5.6: deserved wins against five real ones

The Giants are 5-3-1. Our deserved-standings model, built from how each game played out rather than the final score, gives them 5.6 wins and 3.4 losses. The luck adjustment is minus 0.1 wins, which is close to nothing.

The real conference rank is fifth and the deserved rank is seventh. New York is in the playoff field on both tables. The record is not flattering them, and it is not hiding a better team.

The gap between fifth and seventh matters because Jacksonville comes to East Rutherford in Week 11, and a loss moves the Giants closer to the line on the table that counts. Read Deserved Standings.

2.3 points: the market and the snaps disagree

Over nine games, the betting market expected the Giants to lose by 2.2 points per game. The snap-by-snap model says they deserved to win by 0.1. Their real margin is 0.8 points per game.

That 2.3-point gap between snaps and market ranks tenth of 32 for most underrated by the market. The Giants are 6-3-0 against the closing spread.

This week the line is Jacksonville by 6, with a total of 46.5. Those are context, not a recommendation. They show the market still prices New York below what its snaps have produced. Read Market vs Snaps.

73%: the shotgun pass rate is a tell

The Giants pass on 73% of their shotgun snaps and on 28% of their snaps under center. Their offense is built on the most deep shots and the lowest screen rate in the league.

That is a hard profile for protection. A deep-shot offense with no screens has few ways to get the ball out quickly when the pocket gets crowded. The formation tell ranks ninth of 32 in predictability, so defenses can lean on what they see before the snap.

Watch how Jacksonville plays New York's shotgun looks. Read Scheme DNA.

The Giants host the Jaguars on Sunday, Nov. 22, at 4:25 PM ET on CBS. The forecast for MetLife Stadium is 57 degrees, 7 mph wind and a 58% chance of rain.

How this was reported. Every number in this piece comes from the play-by-play, drive, injury and snap data Pigskin Nightly collects for every game. EPA (expected points added) is from the open nflverse model. We do not use anonymous sources or invent quotes. Read how we write; spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it in the open.