Pigskin Nightly
More
3 live
Latest
Saints DeskSaints converted 8 of 17 third downs and still lost, because the early downs failedjust nowPanthers DeskBryce Young's 18-yard throw to Tremble kept Carolina's best offense of the year honest6 min agoCardinals DeskCardinals' offense lost the early downs in Kansas City and Bam Knight barely touched the ball11 min agoInjuryTre Tucker: Active → Cleared11 min agoChiefs DeskChiefs bury Cardinals by 27 but score once after halftime, and the red zone leaked21 min agoTampa Bay BuccaneersLions Pull Away in Fourth Quarter, Deny Bucs' Upset Bid in DetroitPhiladelphia EaglesSpadaro: 10 takeaways from the Eagles' 19-16 victory over the SteelersESPNMiami Dolphins vs. Buffalo Bills Game HighlightsBears DeskBears' passing game stayed flat against New Orleans, and the sacks decided it26 min agoNew Orleans SaintsNew Orleans Saints succumb to familiar theme in loss to ChicagoInjuryFernando Mendoza: Active → Cleared29 min agoInjuryKeaton Mitchell: Active → Questionable29 min agoInjurySaquon Barkley: Active → Questionable29 min agoDallas CowboysCowboys desatan su ofensiva y aplastan a los Titans 51-30Dallas CowboysCeeDee Lamb on career milestone, Cowboys staying focusedEagles DeskEagles won with a 27 percent success rate and 48 snaps, and Week 12 will test that36 min agoMiami DolphinsGame Recap: Dolphins Defense Makes Big Plays in 26-9 Loss to BuffaloLos Angeles RamsBlake Corum sparking Rams' second-half offense in past four games amid six-game scrimmage touchdown streakBills DeskA punter's 30-yard pass was Buffalo's biggest swing in a 26-9 win over Miami51 min agoArizona CardinalsThe Future Of Beck's Back, And Chiefs AftermathTitans DeskTitans' offense held up in Dallas; the defense never got off the field56 min agoBuccaneers DeskBaker Mayfield's passing graded positive in Detroit, and Tampa Bay still lost by 101 h ago
IND 3FinalHOU 26ARI 7FinalKC 34BAL 33FinalCAR 35MIA 9FinalBUF 26NO 13FinalCHI 21TB 21FinalDET 31TEN 30FinalDAL 51PIT 16FinalPHI 19NYJ 27Q4 9:46LAC 17Win probNYJ 87%JAX 6Q3 10:59NYG 20Win probNYG 83%LV 10Q3 11:59DEN 17Win probDEN 90%MIN SunSF CIN MonWSH

Saints converted 8 of 17 third downs and still lost, because the early downs failed

New Orleans moved the chains on third down against Chicago, but six sacks and a 3.8 yards-per-pass average left the offense with one touchdown.

1321The TapeL 13–21atBEARS
By Saints Desk, Pigskin NightlyNov 22, 6:20 PM ET3 min read

The deciding stretch

The Saints finished with one touchdown drive on four scoring drives, and that ratio is the game. The Bears had two touchdowns on four scoring drives, and the 8-point final, Chicago 21 and New Orleans 13, is the distance between those figures.

The Saints' best drive ran 7 plays and 80 yards for a touchdown. It was the only one of its kind. They had 70 offensive plays to 56 for the Bears and still averaged less per snap: minus 0.136 expected points added (EPA, the points a play adds or costs against what a team normally gets from that spot) against minus 0.098 for Chicago. Their success rate was 37 percent, to 41 percent for the Bears.

The swing

New Orleans went 8-for-17 on third down. Chicago went 5-for-12. On its face that favors the Saints, and it is the wrong thing to take from the game. A team that has to try 17 third downs has spent a lot of first and second downs failing.

The passing game shows where. The Saints averaged 3.8 yards per pass play, and the Bears averaged 6.6. Six sacks cost 35 yards, against two sacks for 16 yards on the other side. Of the Saints' 17 first downs, 15 came through the air and only 2 on the ground.

That split is odd, because the run game was not the problem. The Saints ran for 120 yards at 5.5 per carry, and Travis Etienne Jr. had 14 carries for 76 yards, including a 46-yarder. The offense kept a good runner and gave him few clean chances to set up second-and-short.

The fourth quarter shows the cost. At 8:56, Tyler Shough threw incomplete short left to Noah Fant with M.Sweat in the play, and Chicago's win probability moved 6 points in its favor. Fant finished with 2 catches on 5 targets.

Who moved the needle

Shough was the largest drag in the game: minus 6.7 total EPA across 50 plays. He completed 25 of 42 for 222 yards, one touchdown and one interception, with a rating of 71.7. His 34 rushing yards on 3 carries, with a long of 30, were the best part of his night and do not offset the sacks.

The receivers did their part. Devaughn Vele had 7 catches on 7 targets for 76 yards and the top EPA total on the team at 4.6. Chris Olave caught 9 of 15 targets for 102 yards and added 3.4. Alvin Kamara posted 2.0 EPA on just 2 plays. CJ Donaldson went the other way: four catches for 12 yards, minus 3.9 EPA, and a fumble in the second quarter at 14:28 that Chicago recovered at the New Orleans 41 for a 5-point swing against the Saints.

On defense, Jonas Sanker and Colby Wooden each had a sack and a tackle for loss. Danny Stutsman led the group with 9 tackles. Kool-Aid McKinstry and Stutsman each broke up a pass. The defense held Chicago to 312 total yards, which is not enough on a day the offense gave up so many.

Where it leaves them

The Saints are 3-7 with a point differential of minus 42 and have lost two straight. The home mark is 1-5, and the road mark is a better 2-2. They sit third in the NFC South, level with Tampa Bay and Atlanta at 3-7, with Carolina ahead at 5-5.

The argument from this game is narrow. A third-down rate of 8-for-17 will not hold across a season, and the passing numbers on early downs are the part that carries forward. Fix those and the third-down luck matters less.

The next test is at Cincinnati on Sunday, Nov. 29, at 1:00 PM ET on CBS. Shough was sacked six times in Chicago, and that is the number to track in Week 12.

How this was reported. Every number in this piece comes from the play-by-play, drive, injury and snap data Pigskin Nightly collects for every game. EPA (expected points added) is from the open nflverse model. We do not use anonymous sources or invent quotes. Read how we write; spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it in the open.