Bryce Young's 18-yard throw to Tremble kept Carolina's best offense of the year honest
Carolina beat Baltimore 35-33 with a 51 percent success rate, but four Ravens turnovers did more for the 5-5 record than the offense did.
CAR
The deciding stretch
Bryce Young's 18-yard completion to T.Tremble at the Baltimore 23 with 2:49 left moved Carolina's win probability by 16 points. It was the Panthers' best swing in a game with several large ones, and it set up the only points they scored in the fourth quarter, a field goal. Baltimore had scored seven in that quarter.
The throw was typical of the afternoon. Young finished 22 of 30 for 254 yards and two touchdowns, with one interception and a 106.8 passer rating. Carolina's EPA per dropback was 0.094. EPA, or expected points added, is the number of points a play adds or costs compared with what the down, distance and field position were worth before the snap.
Over 67 plays the Panthers had a 51 percent success rate and 0.063 EPA per play. Baltimore had 44 percent and 0.037 over 61 plays. That is a real edge, but it is a small one, and it belongs to a team that won by two.
The swing
The turnover column is where the game was really decided. Carolina gave the ball away once. Baltimore did it four times. Turnovers swing from week to week more than almost anything else in the sport, and a three-turnover edge is the kind of gift that rarely shows up twice in a row.
Carolina also needed it. Baltimore's D.Walker took a second-quarter kickoff back 86 yards for a touchdown, a 16-point swing against the Panthers. D.Henry's 15-yard touchdown run with 6:32 left cost them another 16. Baltimore had 421 total yards to Carolina's 378.
The Panthers were 5 of 13 on third down and 3 of 6 in the red zone. Both numbers are ordinary. The offense did enough to win, and the turnovers made the margin look comfortable.
Who moved the needle
Darren Waller caught three passes for 42 yards and produced 3.3 total EPA on those three plays, the best figure on the roster. Mitchell Evans added 2.8 on five catches for 44 yards and a touchdown. Tetairoa McMillan led the team with nine targets, six catches and 71 yards, and scored once. Jalen Coker caught four for 47, including a 35-yarder.
The run game was less useful. Chuba Hubbard carried 27 times for 120 yards and two touchdowns, which is 4.4 a carry. The team's EPA per rush was 0.034, barely above zero. Trevor Etienne's six carries cost 0.4 EPA. Young's two scrambles lost two yards and cost 1.6 EPA, the worst line on the team.
On defense, Princely Umanmielen had 1.5 sacks and two quarterback hits. Devin Lloyd added half a sack. Together they accounted for both of the sacks Carolina took off Baltimore, for 12 yards. Tyrel Dodson, who made the closing interception, also had eight tackles and a pass defensed.
Where it leaves them
Carolina is 5-5 with a point differential of minus 15 (254 scored, 269 allowed). It has won two straight and holds the fourth seed in the conference as the leader of an NFC South in which every other team is 3-7. The record is real, but the scoring margin says the Panthers are an average team in a weak division, not a team that has pulled away from one.
The efficiency numbers show a passing game that is working. They do not show an offense that wins without help. A team that depends on a three-turnover edge and on 0.034 EPA per rush will drift back toward .500 unless the ground game improves.
Next up is Monday, Nov. 30 at Tampa Bay, a 3-7 team, at 8:15 p.m. ET on ESPN. Carolina plays on the road for the first time since beating Baltimore, with a 3-2 road record and a division lead to protect.