Pigskin Nightly
More
7 live
Latest
IND 3FinalHOU 26ARI 7Q2 0:00KC 27Win probKC 99%BAL 26Q2 2:22CAR 22Win probCAR 53%MIA 3Q2 1:24BUF 20Win probBUF 99%NO 7Q2 0:54CHI 16Win probCHI 89%TB 7Q2 0:00DET 10Win probDET 68%TEN 6Q2 1:47DAL 27Win probDAL 97%PIT 3Q2 0:00PHI 13Win probPHI 73%NYJ SunLAC JAX SunNYG LV SunDEN MIN SunSF CIN MonWSH
Colts DeskThe Verdict

Colts beat the Dolphins 24-22 in a game the snaps gave to Miami

Indianapolis posted a 19% deserved win probability and a minus-0.28 EPA per snap, and still left Week 10 with a win.

OffenseThe VerdictLuckyDeserved 19% · Week 10
By Colts Desk, Pigskin NightlyNov 17, 12:01 PM ET3 min read

The verdict

The snaps gave the Colts a 19% chance. Played like that, they win about one game in five, and Sunday was the one. Indianapolis beat Miami 24-22 at home, and the win was lucky.

The Dolphins played like a team 4.9 points better. A team that plays that way wins 81% of the time. Miami lost anyway.

What the score hid

The Colts averaged minus-0.28 EPA per snap. EPA, expected points added, measures how much each play moves the scoring forecast for the drive. The Dolphins were at minus-0.15, which is also negative, but better. Neither offense moved the ball well. Indianapolis was a little worse at it.

The success rates tell the same story at a lower volume: 36% for the Colts, 32% for Miami. The Colts won more plays by a small margin and still lost the EPA contest. Efficiency on the line of scrimmage was not what decided this game.

Luck did. The Colts collected 9.3 luck points and the Dolphins lost 5.5. That gap is how a 19% team ends up with a win.

The swing play came at 1:41 of the fourth quarter. K.McCord threw short middle to K.Coleman, and J.Tuimoloau got a hand in. The pass fell incomplete, and Miami lost 21 percentage points of win probability on one snap.

The calls

Indianapolis drew four flags that moved the game by 3% or more, all against the Colts and all for Miami. The biggest was defensive pass interference at 11:54 of the fourth quarter, a 9-yard penalty worth 8%. Another pass interference call in the second quarter cost 15 yards and 7%. A face mask at the start of the fourth and an illegal contact call at 6:17 followed. That last one wiped out an interception.

The Colts still won the flag war on the scoreboard, which says something about how much the Dolphins left on the field.

On fourth down, Shane Steichen made three decisions against the model, and none was costly. He went for it on fourth-and-5 from the Miami 43 in the second quarter, where the model preferred a field goal, and the offense was stopped. That was a toss-up that cost 0.2 expected points. He kicked on fourth-and-1 from the 33 in the third quarter, where the model leaned toward going. The kick was good, and the call cost another 0.2. He punted on fourth-and-5 from his own 46-yard line at 7:54 of the fourth quarter, up in win probability at 72%. The model said go, at a cost of 0.1.

The small leaks add up. Steichen is fair to question but not to condemn for this game. The bigger issue is the season, which is covered below.

The trend

The record is 3-7, and the Colts have 3.1 deserved wins. The luck sheet nets out at minus-0.1 wins, which ranks 16th of 32 and puts Indianapolis in the middle of the league. This was the Colts' only win while lucky this season, and no game has been taken from them.

The Chicken Index is where the problem sits. The model recommended going for it 12 times this season, and Steichen went six times, for a 50% index that ranks 12th most timid of 32. Fourth-down decisions have cost 5.3 expected points across 53 graded situations, including three clear misses.

The season-long net EPA per snap is minus-0.139, 28th in the league. That figure fits a 3-7 team better than Sunday's score does.

Next up is Houston on Thursday, Nov. 19, at 8:15 PM ET on Prime Video, a road game on a short week.

How this was reported. Every number in this piece comes from the play-by-play, drive, injury and snap data Pigskin Nightly collects for every game. EPA (expected points added) is from the open nflverse model. We do not use anonymous sources or invent quotes. Read how we write; spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it in the open.