Colts' fifth-ranked run game meets a Dolphins defense allowing 49 percent success
Indianapolis ranks 5th rushing and last in the league against the run, and Miami ranks 32nd in total defense, so both lines will be tested at Lucas Oil Stadium.

Line IND -3.5The matchup in numbers
The Colts rank fifth in rush offense and 32nd in rush defense. Both ranks matter on Sunday, because Miami's defense is the worst in the league by expected points added (EPA, a measure of how much each play moves the scoreboard) at 0.116 allowed per play. Opponents succeed on 49 percent of plays against the Dolphins. The Colts defense allows 0.075 EPA per play and a 43 percent success rate, which ranks 27th.
Indianapolis is 2-7 and has lost five straight, most recently 27-23 to the Cowboys in Week 9 after a 42-7 loss at Jacksonville in Week 8. Miami is 1-7 and fell 19-9 to the Lions last week. Kickoff is Sunday at 1:00 PM ET on CBS.
Where they can win it
The Colts' best unit is the one that blocks for the run. Jonathan Taylor has 652 yards on 160 rushing plays, though his EPA per play is -0.09 and his success rate is 41 percent. Seth McGowan has 208 yards on 43 plays at 0.07 EPA per play and a 42 percent success rate, the better efficiency of the two.
Miami ranks 22nd against the run and 32nd against the pass. The Colts offense ranks 29th overall with a 42 percent success rate and 31st in pass offense, so the run is the more likely way to move the ball. A third-and-short that Taylor converts keeps Daniel Jones out of obvious passing downs, where his season line is -0.2 EPA per play on 337 plays.
In the passing game, Josh Downs leads the Colts' regulars at 0.27 EPA per play on 57 targets, and Keenan Allen has a 53 percent success rate on 58. Both can work against a pass defense ranked last.
The worry
The Colts' run defense is the worry. A 32nd-ranked unit gives Miami's backs room even though the Dolphins rank 23rd in rush offense. Ollie Gordon II has 463 yards on 107 carries, with a 35 percent success rate and -0.05 EPA per play. Those numbers are poor, but the Colts' front has not shown it can turn poor numbers into stops.
The Dolphins' receivers are efficient on a small volume of targets. Caleb Douglas has 296 yards on 27 targets at 0.37 EPA per play and a 70 percent success rate. Greg Dulcich is at 0.35 EPA per play on 33.
The Colts are 1-3 at home this season, and they have lost to the Titans, who are 1-7, and the Cowboys within the last four weeks.
Availability
Indianapolis lists long snapper Luke Rhodes and linebacker Akeem Davis-Gaither, both starters, as out. Linebacker Jaylon Carlies, defensive tackle Jerry Tillery, tight end Mo Alie-Cox and tackle Jalen Travis are also out. Receiver Alec Pierce and defensive end Arden Key are on injured reserve.
Miami's center Aaron Brewer is out with a concussion, which removes a starter from the middle of the Dolphins' line. Long snapper Tucker Addington is questionable. Quarterback Malik Willis is on injured reserve with an abdomen injury. Defensive tackle Zach Sieler is also on injured reserve. Receiver Chris Bell is doubtful, and Malik Herring, Jared Wayne and Will Kacmarek are questionable.
The Colts are 3.5-point favorites with a total of 38.5, which frames the game as a low-scoring meeting of two struggling teams and is context, not a pick.
Next up for Indianapolis is the Colts' run defense against whichever back Miami hands the ball to, the first snaps that will show whether the 32nd-ranked unit can hold at Lucas Oil Stadium.