Bills beat the Jets by 18.7 points on the snaps, not just the scoreboard
Buffalo's 31-12 win at the Jets was earned on every measure, though eight wins on a 6.4-win résumé keeps the luck sheet crowded.


The verdict
Played like that, the Bills win more than 99% of the time. The snaps gave them an 18.7-point margin over the New York Jets, and the final of 31-12 was a 19-point result, so the scoreboard and the film agree. This one was earned.
The Bills averaged 0.3 EPA per snap. EPA is expected points added, the points a play is worth compared with what the down and distance were worth before the snap. The Jets averaged -0.09, which means their average snap left them worse off than before it.
What the score hid
The success rate was closer than the margin suggests: 47% for Buffalo against 44% for New York. The gap came from the size of the plays, not the frequency of the good ones.
The swing play shows it. In the third quarter, at 9:54, J.Allen threw deep right to D.Kincaid, who was pushed out of bounds at the Jets 8 for 54 yards. That one throw added 12% of win probability, the most of any snap in the game. It is the explosive side of the Allen ledger, the throw that pays for the ones that could have gone the other way.
Luck was not the story. The Bills had -0.9 luck points and the Jets -0.6, so neither side got a bounce that mattered.
The calls
The flags leaned one way. All four of the heaviest went against New York and for Buffalo: defensive pass interference for 17 yards in the first quarter (6% of win probability), offensive too many men on the field for 5 yards (4%), and offensive holding for 10 yards in both the second quarter (4%) and the third (3%). The Jets handed over yards and downs, and the Bills took them.
On fourth down, head coach Joe Brady made the aggressive call when the model wanted it. He went on fourth-and-1 from 63 yards out and converted. He went again on fourth-and-1 from the 21 and converted again. The field goal on fourth-and-13 from the 19 was the clear choice and it was good.
The one miss was small. On fourth-and-6 from 44 yards out in the first quarter, Brady punted where the model preferred a field goal, a cost of 0.5 expected points. The model called it a tossup, and Buffalo won by 19 anyway.
The trend
Buffalo is 8-1 with 6.4 deserved wins, a gap of 1.6 wins that ranks second among the 32 teams for luckiest. The Bills are 4-1 in one-score games. Opponent kicking has been the biggest source, at 5.5 luck points of the 6.1 total, with fumble recoveries adding 0.5. Net EPA of 0.134 per snap ranks sixth, so the team is good, only not quite as good as 8-1 says.
On the Chicken Index, Buffalo sits at 22%, 23rd of 32 on the most-timid list. Brady's teams have gone on seven of the nine fourth downs where the model recommended going, out of 43 graded. The cost is 2.9 expected points all season, with one clear miss.
The flags have helped too: 75 penalties against Buffalo for 618 yards, yet a net gain of 8% in win probability from the officiating.
Next up is the Miami Dolphins at home on Sunday, Nov. 22, at 1:00 PM ET on CBS.