Pigskin Nightly
More
7 live
Latest
IND 3FinalHOU 26ARI 7Q2 4:32KC 17Win probKC 93%BAL 12Q2 10:52CAR 7Win probBAL 51%MIA 3Q2 9:44BUF 13Win probBUF 97%NO 0Q2 10:16CHI 10Win probCHI 90%TB 0Q2 5:26DET 7Win probDET 77%TEN 3Q2 12:40DAL 20Win probDAL 95%PIT 0Q2 9:23PHI 13Win probPHI 76%NYJ SunLAC JAX SunNYG LV SunDEN MIN SunSF CIN MonWSH
Bills DeskThe Lab Report

Bills' 8-1 record runs 1.6 wins ahead of what the snaps say they earned

One decisive play per win has carried more weight than any loss has cost, and the deserved table puts Buffalo fourth in the conference, not first.

MilestoneThe Lab Report6.4Deserved wins · The Lab
By Bills Desk, Pigskin NightlyNov 19, 5:10 PM ET2 min read

The most surprising number in the Lab this week is 1.76. That is how many games' worth of win probability a single decisive play has saved across the Bills' wins, against 0.28 lost on one play across their losses. Buffalo is 8-1, and the other tables say the record is a little richer than the football underneath it.

1.76 games: one play keeps saving them

Sliding Doors finds the one swing play in each game and adds up what it was worth. In wins, those plays total 1.76 games of win probability. In the loss, the total is 0.28.

No Buffalo loss is one play away from flipping, per the same tool. For a team that lives on big throws, that points to wins that were close in the second half and a loss that was not. Miami arrives at Highmark Stadium on Sunday, Nov. 22 at 1:00 PM ET on CBS, and Buffalo is a 16.5-point favorite, which leaves little room for a single play to matter. The context is the line, not a pick.

The numbers are in Sliding Doors.

6.4 deserved wins: the table is kinder than the film

Based on how the games were played, Buffalo deserves 6.4 wins and 2.6 losses. That leaves 1.6 wins of luck. The Bills rank first in the conference on the real table and fourth on the deserved one, and they are in the playoff field on both.

The gap is real but not alarming. A team can lose a seed to it, not a berth. Week 11 is a chance to close it with a comfortable result rather than a nervy one.

The full split is at Deserved Standings.

9.8 points: the margin beats both models

The betting market expected Buffalo to win by 4.2 points per game across nine games. Snap-level play says 7.4, which is 3.2 points higher than the market. The real margin is 9.8, or 2.4 above the snap-level figure. The Bills rank seventh of 32 among teams the market has underrated, and they are 7-2-0 against the closing spread.

So the market has been wrong in Buffalo's favor, and the results have run ahead of the snaps as well. Sunday's 16.5-point line is the largest gap the market has asked of them in this comparison, and it is context only.

The comparison lives at Market vs Snaps.

82%: the cap is mostly on the field

Buffalo has spent $243.6 million of a $314.6 million league cap figure, and 82 percent of it is on the field. Paid vs Played ranks the Bills 11th of 32 in value. Injured reserve holds $14.3 million, and players not playing account for $29.4 million.

The best bargain is Deone Walker, an interior lineman at a $1.27 million cap hit. He sits in the 44th percentile for pay and the 91st for playing time, at 68 percent of snaps. The least value is Dawson Knox, a tight end at $8.55 million, in the 94th percentile for pay and the 46th for playing time.

Walker's snaps against Miami are the interior-line number to track on Sunday. The full breakdown is in Paid vs Played.

The next data point is Sunday's game against the Dolphins in Orchard Park, where Buffalo will try to move the real and deserved tables closer together.

How this was reported. Every number in this piece comes from the play-by-play, drive, injury and snap data Pigskin Nightly collects for every game. EPA (expected points added) is from the open nflverse model. We do not use anonymous sources or invent quotes. Read how we write; spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it in the open.