Pigskin Nightly
More
7 live
Latest
IND 3FinalHOU 26ARI 7Q2 0:00KC 27Win probKC 99%BAL 26Q2 2:22CAR 22Win probCAR 53%MIA 3Q2 1:24BUF 20Win probBUF 99%NO 7Q2 0:54CHI 16Win probCHI 89%TB 7Q2 0:00DET 10Win probDET 68%TEN 6Q2 1:39DAL 27Win probDAL 97%PIT 3Q2 0:00PHI 13Win probPHI 73%NYJ SunLAC JAX SunNYG LV SunDEN MIN SunSF CIN MonWSH
49ers DeskThe Verdict

49ers earned a 46-40 win in Dallas, and the snaps say it should have been wider

San Francisco's snaps were worth 14.2 points of margin against a 6-point final, and a 74-yard throw on a short route was the biggest swing.

The VerdictAir attackEarnedDeserved >99% · Week 10
By 49ers Desk, Pigskin NightlyNov 17, 12:00 PM ET2 min read

The verdict

Played like that, the 49ers win 100% of the time. The snaps gave them a deserved margin of 14.2 points over the Dallas Cowboys, and the final was 46-40. That makes this win earned, with 8.2 points of margin left on the field.

The record is now 8-1. The deserved-win total for the season is 8.1, so the tape and the standings agree.

What the score hid

EPA, or expected points added, credits each snap with the points it is worth, based on where it leaves the drive compared with where it started. San Francisco averaged 0.42 EPA per snap. Dallas averaged 0.13, a gap of 0.29.

The success rate was much closer: 49% for the 49ers, 47% for the Cowboys. The Cowboys stayed on schedule almost as often. San Francisco's plays simply paid more when they worked.

The swing play shows how. In the second quarter, at 2:43, B.Purdy threw short right out of shotgun to C.McCaffrey, who took it 74 yards for a touchdown. The play added 21% to San Francisco's win probability. The route was short, and almost all of the yardage came after the catch. That conversion of a short throw into a long gain is the core of this offense.

Luck did not help the 49ers. They were at minus 2.3 luck points for the game, and Dallas was at plus 1.1. Dallas got more from the bounces and still lost by six.

The calls

Kyle Shanahan had two graded fourth downs, and he matched the model on both. In the first quarter, at 0:14, he punted on fourth-and-7 from 62 yards out. The model called it a tossup and also picked the punt. In the second quarter, at 6:57, he kicked a field goal on fourth-and-10 from the 10-yard line, which the model rated a clear call. The kick was good. Neither decision cost any expected points.

The flags went against San Francisco early. Roughing the Passer in the first quarter, at 14:50, cost 15 yards and 5% of win probability. A false start on the 49ers in the third quarter, at 14:51, cost another 3%. Dallas gave back some of it with a false start in the second quarter and a defensive offside in the third, each worth 3% to San Francisco.

The trend

The season sheet says the 49ers are neither lucky nor robbed. Their luck wins stand at minus 0.1, which ranks 16th among the 32 teams, with the luckiest first. They are 4-0 in one-score games, yet no win this year came while lucky, and none of the games was robbed.

The total luck figure is minus 9.3 points. Opponent kicking accounts for minus 4.8 of that, and fumble recoveries for minus 1.8. The penalty ledger is also negative: 61 flags against, 545 yards, and a net of minus 32% of win probability. The team's net EPA per snap is 0.213, which ranks second in the league.

Shanahan's weak spot is still the Chicken Index of 57%. The model recommended going for it on 7 of 25 graded fourth downs, and he went on 3 of them. Those decisions have cost 4.2 expected points, including 2 clear misses. This game did not add to that total.

The next test is the Minnesota Vikings in Week 11. The game is at home on Sunday, Nov 22, at 8:20 PM ET on NBC.

How this was reported. Every number in this piece comes from the play-by-play, drive, injury and snap data Pigskin Nightly collects for every game. EPA (expected points added) is from the open nflverse model. We do not use anonymous sources or invent quotes. Read how we write; spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it in the open.