Pigskin Nightly
More
7 live
Latest
IND 3FinalHOU 26ARI 7Q2 7:19KC 14Win probKC 94%BAL 12Q2 13:01CAR 7Win probBAL 55%MIA 0Q2 10:41BUF 13Win probBUF 98%NO 0Q2 11:34CHI 10Win probCHI 90%TB 0Q2 5:41DET 7Win probDET 77%TEN 3Q2 12:59DAL 20Win probDAL 96%PIT 0Q2 10:50PHI 13Win probPHI 78%NYJ SunLAC JAX SunNYG LV SunDEN MIN SunSF CIN MonWSH
Patriots DeskThe Verdict

Lions earned every point of a 35-10 win over the Patriots

Detroit's snaps rated a margin of 29.8 points, and New England's 33 percent success rate left no room to call this one lucky or close.

The VerdictDeservedDeserved 0% · Week 10
By Patriots Desk, Pigskin NightlyNov 17, 12:10 PM ET2 min read

The verdict

The Lions earned it. The snaps said Lions by 29.8 points, which gives Detroit a deserved win probability of more than 99%. Played like that, the Patriots win almost never, and a 35-10 final in Detroit is the honest read of the afternoon.

No one was robbed. The luck ledger for this game leaned slightly toward New England, 1.2 luck points to minus 1.7 for the Lions, so the scoreboard did not flatter Detroit.

What the score hid

Nothing was hidden. New England's offense produced minus 0.31 EPA per snap. EPA is expected points added, the change in a team's scoring outlook on each play. Detroit's offense ran at 0.24. The Patriots' success rate was 33%, against 51% for the Lions.

The swing play came early. With 6:26 left in the first quarter, J.Goff threw short right to A.St. Brown, who took it 56 yards for a touchdown. The play was worth 18 percentage points of win probability to Detroit, the biggest single swing of the game.

New England had a break in the same quarter. Detroit was flagged for defensive pass interference at 5:12, a 30-yard penalty worth 6 points of win probability to the Patriots. They did not turn it into anything that changed the game's direction.

The calls

The heaviest flags all came in the first quarter, and three of the four went against New England: a delay of game at 9:43, an illegal block above the waist at 6:13 and a false start at 10:05. The delay and the false start cost 5 yards each, the block 10. Each moved win probability by 2 to 3 points toward Detroit. Those are the marks of an offense out of rhythm.

The fourth-down decisions give Mike Vrabel little to answer for. Five were graded, and the Patriots matched the model on all five, losing 0 expected points on them. They kicked a field goal from fourth-and-15 at the Detroit 15 and punted on fourth-and-16, fourth-and-9, fourth-and-14 and fourth-and-9. Two of those were clear calls and the rest leans, and none was close to a go-for-it spot.

That is the problem. A coach is not at fault for punting when his offense faces fourth-and-14 from its own 29. The failure came on the downs before it, and the 33% success rate shows where.

The trend

The Patriots are 5-5 with 4.8 deserved wins, so luck has added 0.2 wins, 13th among 32 teams. The luck is mostly neutral: fumble recovery luck is minus 0.8, opponent kicking luck is 2.4, and the total is minus 1.2 luck points. Their one-score record is 3-2.

The Chicken Index under Vrabel stands at 43%. Of 42 graded fourth downs, the model recommended going on seven, and New England went on four. The cost is 5.2 expected points across the season, with one clear miss.

The larger drag is the flags. The Patriots have 73 penalties for 545 yards, a net flag swing of minus 9 percentage points of win probability. Their net EPA per snap is minus 0.053, 21st in the league. A team with that profile is a .500 team on merit, not a hidden contender, and nothing in the luck numbers suggests a correction is coming.

The next test is at the Los Angeles Chargers in Week 12, Sunday, Nov. 29, at 8:20 PM ET on NBC.

How this was reported. Every number in this piece comes from the play-by-play, drive, injury and snap data Pigskin Nightly collects for every game. EPA (expected points added) is from the open nflverse model. We do not use anonymous sources or invent quotes. Read how we write; spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it in the open.