Pigskin Nightly
More
7 live
Latest
IND 3FinalHOU 26ARI 7Q2 0:00KC 27Win probKC 99%BAL 26Q2 2:22CAR 22Win probCAR 53%MIA 3Q2 1:24BUF 20Win probBUF 99%NO 7Q2 0:54CHI 16Win probCHI 89%TB 7Q2 0:00DET 10Win probDET 68%TEN 6Q2 1:47DAL 27Win probDAL 97%PIT 3Q2 0:00PHI 13Win probPHI 73%NYJ SunLAC JAX SunNYG LV SunDEN MIN SunSF CIN MonWSH
Packers DeskThe Verdict

Packers' 30-10 loss to the Vikings was earned, and a fumble at the GB 10 started it

Played like that, Green Bay wins 5% of the time against Minnesota, and a first-quarter fumble on a short pass was the biggest swing of the game.

TurnoversThe VerdictDeservedDeserved 5% · Week 10
By Packers Desk, Pigskin NightlyNov 17, 11:50 AM ET3 min read

The verdict

The snaps gave the Packers a 5% chance against the Minnesota Vikings in Week 10. Played like that, Green Bay wins one game in 20. The 30-10 loss at Lambeau was earned.

The snaps put the deserved margin at Minnesota by 9.0 points. The scoreboard said 20, so the final ran 11 points harsher than the play did. That gap is real, but it does not change the ruling. Nothing was stolen from the Packers on Sunday.

What the score hid

EPA, or expected points added, measures how much each snap moved the scoring expectation for its offense. The Packers averaged -0.12 EPA per snap. The Vikings averaged 0.06. The Packers' success rate was 39%, against 45% for Minnesota.

Neither gap is large. The Vikings were not dominant on a snap-by-snap basis, and Green Bay's offense was below the line on average. The luck ledger explains most of why the score stretched. The Packers finished at -3.8 luck points and the Vikings at 5.1.

The swing play came early. In the first quarter, with 12:49 on the clock, J.Love threw short right to M.Redman out of no-huddle shotgun. Redman gained 5 yards to the GB 10, and A.Van Ginkel forced a fumble and recovered it. That one snap moved win probability by 17 points. A short, quick throw from deep in their own territory turned into the most expensive snap of the day.

The flags that followed balanced out. An illegal block above the waist on Green Bay cost 6 points of win probability at 13:21 of the first quarter. Minnesota then gave back three of its own, each worth 4: a false start, roughing the passer and a face mask. The Packers got 35 yards of penalty relief that quarter and still lost.

The calls

Matt LaFleur had a clean day on fourth down. All three decisions matched the model, each graded clear, with zero expected points lost.

He kicked on fourth-and-16 from the Minnesota 35 in the first quarter, and the kick missed. He punted on fourth-and-26 from his own 10 in the second quarter. He kicked a field goal on fourth-and-10 from the 22 with 0:23 left in the third, and that one was good. None of those is an argument for going. The miss was execution, not strategy.

The season picture is a fairer test. Of 45 graded fourth downs, the model recommended going on 11, and LaFleur went on 6. That is a Chicken Index of 46%, 15th most timid of 32 teams. It has cost the Packers 4.2 expected points on fourth down, with no clear misses. That is a middling profile, not a timid one.

The trend

Green Bay is 6-4 and the snaps say 5.4 deserved wins. That is 0.6 wins of luck, seventh luckiest of 32 teams. The Packers are 3-1 in one-score games and have won one game while lucky. They have not been robbed in any.

Total luck sits at 3.4 points, including 1.4 from fumble recoveries. Sunday's fumble went the other way. Flags have also hurt: 80 penalties for 650 yards, with a net flag cost of 7 points of win probability.

The underlying number is steadier than the record. Green Bay's net EPA per snap is 0.048, 10th in the league. That is a good team that has been slightly overpaid in the standings. The luck should even out.

The next game is in Week 12, at the Los Angeles Rams on Wednesday, Nov 25 at 8:00 PM ET on Netflix.

How this was reported. Every number in this piece comes from the play-by-play, drive, injury and snap data Pigskin Nightly collects for every game. EPA (expected points added) is from the open nflverse model. We do not use anonymous sources or invent quotes. Read how we write; spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it in the open.