Pigskin Nightly
More
7 live
Latest
IND 3FinalHOU 26ARI 7Q2 0:00KC 27Win probKC 99%BAL 26Q2 2:22CAR 22Win probCAR 53%MIA 3Q2 1:24BUF 20Win probBUF 99%NO 7Q2 0:54CHI 16Win probCHI 89%TB 7Q2 0:00DET 10Win probDET 68%TEN 6Q2 1:47DAL 27Win probDAL 97%PIT 3Q2 0:00PHI 13Win probPHI 73%NYJ SunLAC JAX SunNYG LV SunDEN MIN SunSF CIN MonWSH
Dolphins DeskThe Verdict

Dolphins lost to the Colts 24-22 in a game their snaps said they won

Miami played like a 4.9-point better team, and the 81% deserved win probability makes this one robbed, even with every flag going their way.

The VerdictDolphinsRobbedDeserved 81% · Week 10
By Dolphins Desk, Pigskin NightlyNov 17, 11:50 AM ET2 min read

The verdict

The snaps gave the Dolphins an 81% chance against the Colts. Played like that, they win four times out of five. They lost 24-22, so the engine calls this one robbed.

The deserved margin was 4.9 points in Miami's favor. That is the gap between the scoreboard and the film.

What the score hid

Neither offense was good. Miami averaged -0.15 EPA per snap, and EPA is expected points added, the points a play adds or costs against the typical result of that down and spot. Indianapolis was worse at -0.28. The Dolphins were less bad on average, and that was the margin.

Success rate told a tighter story. Miami's was 32%. The Colts' was 36%. The Dolphins did not win the down-to-down fight. They won on what each snap was worth.

Luck points did the rest. Miami finished at -5.5 for the game and Indianapolis at 9.3. Two Dolphins field goals missed, one from 29 yards out in the first quarter and one from 33 in the fourth. The biggest swing came at 1:41 of the fourth quarter. K.McCord's shotgun pass to K.Coleman over the short middle fell incomplete with J.Tuimoloau on the play, and it cost Miami 21 points of win probability.

The calls

Miami's problem was not the officials. All four of the heaviest flags went against Indianapolis. Defensive pass interference for 9 yards in the fourth quarter was worth 8 points of win probability, and the 15-yard call in the second was worth 7. A face mask and an illegal contact call that erased an interception added 4 and 3.

The fourth-down calls were mostly sound. Head coach Jeff Hafley punted or kicked when the model said to, and went for it on 4th-and-2 from the 8 in the second quarter, which was stopped. The model's best choice was a go on two others, both 4th-and-3. Hafley punted from 74 yards out in the third quarter, a tossup that cost 0.2 expected points. He punted again at 5:10 of the fourth, from 67 yards out with Miami's win probability at 32%. That one was a lean, and it cost 0.3.

Neither punt lost the game. A team trailing in the fourth quarter that keeps the ball on a 4th-and-3 gives its offense a chance to win it. Hafley did not take it.

The trend

Miami is 1-8. The snaps say the Dolphins deserved 2.4 wins, so their luck is -1.4 wins, 28th among 32 teams with the luckiest first. They are 1-4 in one-score games and have been robbed once.

Total luck sits at -6.2 points. Fumble recoveries account for -2.5 of it, and opponents' kicking has gone 2.8 points their way. Miami has taken 63 penalties for 453 yards, though the net flag effect on win probability is still 17 points in their favor.

On fourth down, the Chicken Index is 38%, 18th among the 32 most timid teams. The model recommended going eight times, and Hafley went five. The cost is 2.6 expected points over 43 graded calls, with no clear misses. The net EPA per snap is -0.111, 25th in the league, so some of the record is earned.

Next up is the Buffalo Bills, on the road, Sunday, Nov. 22 at 1:00 PM ET on CBS.

How this was reported. Every number in this piece comes from the play-by-play, drive, injury and snap data Pigskin Nightly collects for every game. EPA (expected points added) is from the open nflverse model. We do not use anonymous sources or invent quotes. Read how we write; spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it in the open.