Pigskin Nightly
More
7 live
Latest
IND 3FinalHOU 26ARI 7Q2 9:48KC 14Win probKC 93%BAL 12Q2 15:00CAR 7Win probCAR 52%MIA 0Q2 13:16BUF 13Win probBUF 98%NO 0Q2 12:40CHI 3Win probCHI 85%TB 0Q2 9:05DET 7Win probDET 72%TEN 3Q2 13:09DAL 13Win probDAL 94%PIT 0Q2 11:41PHI 13Win probPHI 75%NYJ SunLAC JAX SunNYG LV SunDEN MIN SunSF CIN MonWSH
Commanders DeskThe Verdict

Commanders beat the Giants 24-21 on a 38% performance and three late flags

The snaps favored New York by 1.6 points, but a 32-yard Daniels touchdown and Giants penalties turned Week 10 Washington's way.

The VerdictEarnedDeserved 38% · Week 10
By Commanders Desk, Pigskin NightlyNov 17, 10:11 AM ET2 min read

The verdict

The snaps gave the Commanders a 38% chance against the New York Giants in Week 10. They won 24-21 anyway. That makes this a lucky win: Washington won as the underdog of the snaps, and the Giants were the better team by 1.6 points.

The play that decided it came with 1:05 left in the fourth quarter. J.Daniels threw short middle to S.Diggs for a 32-yard touchdown, worth 32 percentage points of win probability, the biggest swing of the game. The throw was real. The position around it was built in part by three Giants flags in the final quarter.

What the score hid

EPA, expected points added, measures how much each snap moves a team's expected scoring. Washington averaged 0.05 per snap. The Giants averaged 0.06. That is a dead heat with New York a hair ahead.

Success rate was Washington's better number: 58% of snaps against 46% for the Giants. The Commanders stayed on schedule more often, but they did not turn that into more points per snap.

Luck points settled the gap. Washington collected 2.9 in this game and the Giants lost 0.8, a 3.7-point difference. That is larger than the 1.6-point margin by which New York outplayed them.

The calls

All four of the heaviest flags went against the Giants and helped Washington. A fourth-quarter delay of game at 3:27 cost New York 4 yards and 12 points of win probability. A defensive pass interference call at 1:46 gave Washington 33 yards and 11 more. The other two were a first-quarter delay of game at 11:28 (6 points) and a false start at 15:00 of the fourth (3 points). Three of the four came late.

On fourth down, Washington matched the model on five of six graded calls. The exception came at 9:09 of the fourth quarter. On fourth-and-2 from 31 yards out, with a 73% win probability, Dan Quinn went for it and the offense was stopped. The model leaned toward the field goal, and the decision cost 0.4 expected points.

That is a small miss, and Quinn deserves credit for being aggressive. The problem is the rest of his season. Of 53 graded fourth downs, the model recommended going on 8, and Washington went on 2. Its Chicken Index is 75%, fourth most timid of 32 teams. The cost so far is 6.5 expected points, including 2 clear misses.

The trend

Washington is 3-5-1 with 2.9 deserved wins. Its luck wins stand at 0.6, seventh luckiest of 32 teams. The one-score record is 2-3.

The season's total luck points come to 17.1. Fumble recoveries account for 4.1 of them and opponent kicking for 4.4. The Commanders have also drawn 65 penalties for 485 yards, and their net flag win probability stands at 62%. Their net EPA per snap is -0.059, 22nd in the league.

The pattern is a team whose results sit slightly ahead of its snaps, with a head coach whose fourth-down record has left points on the table. The next test is the Cincinnati Bengals at home in Week 11, Monday, Nov. 23, at 8:15 PM ET on ESPN.

How this was reported. Every number in this piece comes from the play-by-play, drive, injury and snap data Pigskin Nightly collects for every game. EPA (expected points added) is from the open nflverse model. We do not use anonymous sources or invent quotes. Read how we write; spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it in the open.