Pigskin Nightly
More
Week 11
Latest
IND 3FinalHOU 26ARI SunKC BAL SunCAR MIA SunBUF NO SunCHI TB SunDET TEN SunDAL PIT SunPHI NYJ SunLAC JAX SunNYG LV SunDEN MIN SunSF CIN MonWSH
Bengals DeskThe Verdict

Bengals beat Steelers by 20, and the snaps say it should have been 22.5

Cincinnati's 38-18 win over Pittsburgh was earned on every metric, even with the luck points running against the winner.

The VerdictGround gameEarnedDeserved >99% · Week 10
By Bengals Desk, Pigskin NightlyNov 17, 2:20 PM ET2 min read

The verdict

The snaps gave the Bengals a deserved win probability of more than 99% against the Steelers. Played like that, Cincinnati wins essentially every time. The film calls Sunday's 38-18 result earned.

The deserved margin was 22.5 points against an actual margin of 20. The scoreboard undersold the Bengals by 2.5 points, which is a rare complaint to file after a blowout.

What the score hid

Cincinnati's offense averaged 0.31 EPA per snap. EPA is expected points added, a measure of how much each play moved the scoring forecast. Pittsburgh's offense averaged -0.08. Success rate ran 59% to 41%, an 18-point gap.

Luck ran the wrong way for the winner. The Bengals' luck points this game were -3.5, and the Steelers' were 5.3. Pittsburgh got the bounces and still lost by 20.

The biggest swing play was a one-yard dive. In the first quarter at 3:17, on fourth-and-1, S.Perine ran right guard for 1 yard to the CIN 46, with J.Brisker making the tackle. It was worth 7% in win probability, the most of any snap. Not every decider needs a highlight reel.

The calls

Zac Taylor had a clean day on fourth down. The model graded three decisions, and he matched it on all three, each rated clear. He kicked on fourth-and-6 from the 6 in the first quarter, and the kick was good. He went on fourth-and-1 at 3:17 and converted. He kicked on fourth-and-8 from the 25 in the second quarter, and that one missed. The model liked the call anyway. A missed kick does not make a bad decision.

The season tells a different story. Of 28 graded fourth downs, the model recommended going on 9, and Taylor went on 3. That puts his Chicken Index at 67%, seventh most timid of 32 teams. It has cost 4.5 expected points, though only one of the misses was clear. Sunday was the right kind of day for him. It was one game.

The flags were lopsided in count but not in cost. Defensive pass interference on Pittsburgh in the second quarter at 15:00 gave Cincinnati 26 yards and a 6% swing. Offensive holding on the Bengals at 13:21 gave back 10 yards and the same 6%. A taunting call at 4:41 cost 15 yards and 3%, and a first-quarter hold at 15:00 cost 10 yards and 2%. That is two holds and a taunt against one interference call. For a team whose passing game depends on clean pockets, the holds are the ones to watch.

The trend

The Bengals are 7-2 with 7.3 deserved wins, so their luck sits at -0.3 wins. That ranks 21st of 32 among the luckiest teams. They are 3-2 in one-score games, have been robbed once, and have not won a game while lucky.

Season luck points total -3.5. Fumble recovery luck accounts for -0.7 of that, and opponent kicking for -1.6. Cincinnati's net EPA per snap is 0.151, fifth in the league. The record is honest, if a shade low, and the underlying numbers say it is closer to rising than falling.

The penalty count is the part that needs fixing. The Bengals have been flagged 63 times for 517 yards. Next up is Week 11 at the Washington Commanders on Monday, Nov 23, at 8:15 PM ET on ESPN.

How this was reported. Every number in this piece comes from the play-by-play, drive, injury and snap data Pigskin Nightly collects for every game. EPA (expected points added) is from the open nflverse model. We do not use anonymous sources or invent quotes. Read how we write; spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it in the open.