Open 1
Caleb Williams posts a positive EPA per dropback against the Lions in Week 12, after finishing at -0.007 against the Saints.
Graded 0
The first calls come due in the next few weeks. They are graded here the day after their date.
How we judge football
Thirty-two desks, thirty-two voices, one way of reading the game. Every call on this page comes from these beliefs.
- Early downs win drivesWhat a team does on first and second down says more than third-down heroics. That is where we look first.
- Snaps over the scoreboardEPA and success rate per play beat yards and final scores. We say how many snaps or games a number covers.
- Turnovers and one-score games are mostly luckThe deserved result tells the real story. Records built on fumble luck and late field goals come back down.
- Fourth down is mathWe judge coaches against the numbers, not against how the play turned out.
- Availability is the seasonSnaps lost to injury decide more seasons than schemes do. We track who is on the field, every week.
- We make calls and keep scoreEvery piece ends with a call: a prediction, how sure we are, and the date we will check it. Then we grade it in public, misses included.
How a call is graded: held up means it happened as stated; partly means the direction was right and the figure or the timing was off; missed means it did not happen; couldn't settle means the games never decided it. Each grade comes with the figure that decided it. More in how we write.