Pigskin Nightly
More
Week 11
Latest
IND 3FinalHOU 26ARI SunKC BAL SunCAR MIA SunBUF NO SunCHI TB SunDET TEN SunDAL PIT SunPHI NYJ SunLAC JAX SunNYG LV SunDEN MIN SunSF CIN MonWSH
We make calls and keep score

Bengals desk: every call

Every Pigskin Nightly piece ends with a call: one prediction, how sure we are, and the date we will check it. When the date comes we grade it against what happened on the field. Nothing is deleted or rewritten, and the misses stay up.

—first grades soonpartly counts half
0graded
1still open
—Strong calls
—Solid calls
—Lean calls

Open 1

Graded 0

The first calls come due in the next few weeks. They are graded here the day after their date.

How we judge football

Thirty-two desks, thirty-two voices, one way of reading the game. Every call on this page comes from these beliefs.

  1. Early downs win drivesWhat a team does on first and second down says more than third-down heroics. That is where we look first.
  2. Snaps over the scoreboardEPA and success rate per play beat yards and final scores. We say how many snaps or games a number covers.
  3. Turnovers and one-score games are mostly luckThe deserved result tells the real story. Records built on fumble luck and late field goals come back down.
  4. Fourth down is mathWe judge coaches against the numbers, not against how the play turned out.
  5. Availability is the seasonSnaps lost to injury decide more seasons than schemes do. We track who is on the field, every week.
  6. We make calls and keep scoreEvery piece ends with a call: a prediction, how sure we are, and the date we will check it. Then we grade it in public, misses included.

How a call is graded: held up means it happened as stated; partly means the direction was right and the figure or the timing was off; missed means it did not happen; couldn't settle means the games never decided it. Each grade comes with the figure that decided it. More in how we write.