Panthers beat the Saints 20-17 on a 54-yard kick, and the snaps back it up
Carolina's 88% deserved win probability says the 20-17 win at New Orleans was earned, even on a day both offenses finished below zero in EPA.

OffenseThe verdict
R.Fitzgerald's 54-yard field goal with 0:02 left added 29 percentage points of win probability, and it decided a 20-17 game. The snaps say the kick was not a bailout. Played like that, the Panthers win 88% of the time, and the engine puts the deserved margin at 6.4 points.
The verdict is earned. It was not a pretty earned win, but the Panthers beat the Saints on the numbers as well as on the scoreboard.
What the score hid
Both offenses were bad. Carolina averaged -0.07 EPA per snap. EPA is expected points added, the points a play is worth against what a team could expect from that down, distance and field position. New Orleans averaged -0.20, so the Panthers won the per-snap gap by 0.13.
Success rate does not separate them. Both teams finished at 34%. The Panthers won on the quality of what they gained and what they gave away, not on staying on schedule.
Luck points leaned the other way from the final margin. The Panthers got 0.5 from the game's bounces and the Saints lost 1.4. That is a small tilt toward Carolina. It does not explain an 88% deserved win probability.
The calls
The flags swung the fourth quarter. A defensive pass interference call on New Orleans at 0:28 gave Carolina 30 yards and moved win probability by 20 points. That was the heaviest flag of the day, and it set up the kick.
The Panthers took penalties too. A face mask at 1:10 cost 15 yards and 13 points of win probability. Defensive pass interference on Carolina at 4:40 cost 17 yards and 10 points. Unnecessary roughness in the third quarter at 8:46 cost 15 yards and 7 points.
On fourth down, Dave Canales matched the model on seven of nine graded calls. He went on fourth-and-2 from the 3 and was stopped. He went on fourth-and-2 from the 2 and scored. He converted fourth-and-1 from his own 26.
Two calls cost something. On fourth-and-13 from the Saints' 41 in the first quarter, he punted where the model wanted a field goal, a loss of 0.9 expected points. At fourth-and-5 from the Carolina 58 with 9:40 left in the fourth quarter, he punted where the model leaned toward going, a loss of 0.1. The first was a clear miss and the second a tossup. Neither moved the result.
The trend
The season sheet is more patient than the week. Carolina is 4-5 with 4.5 deserved wins, so the luck ledger reads -0.5 wins. That ranks 25th of 32 in luck, with 1 is the luckiest. The Panthers are 2-3 in one-score games and have been robbed once. They have not won a game while lucky.
Total luck points stand at -5.1. Opponent kicking accounts for -3.6 of that, and fumble recoveries add -0.4. The penalty ledger is heavy as well. Carolina has been flagged 87 times for 787 yards, and the flags have netted -52 points of win probability.
On fourth down, the Chicken Index is 25%. Canales has gone on 6 of the 8 situations where the model recommended it, which ranks the Panthers 22nd of 32 among the most timid teams. Across 47 graded fourth downs, the team has lost 4.1 expected points, with 2 clear misses.
Carolina's net EPA per snap is 0.009, 14th in the league. The deserved record is a half-win better than the real one, and Sunday's game did not change that.
The Panthers host the Baltimore Ravens on Sunday, Nov. 22 at 1:00 PM ET on Fox. The numbers to follow are the flag count and the first fourth-and-short.