Chuba Hubbard's 34-yard catch sets up Panthers' 20-17 win in New Orleans
A 34-yard catch, a 30-yard pass interference call and a 54-yard field goal decided a game the Panthers did not win on efficiency.


The deciding stretch
Chuba Hubbard caught a 34-yard pass from Bryce Young with 2:23 left in the fourth quarter, and the ball came to rest at the New Orleans 1. The play moved the Panthers' win probability by 31 points, the largest swing of the game in their favor.
The Saints answered. C.Smyth kicked a 55-yard field goal with 0:41 left, which cost Carolina 22 points of win probability and left the score tied at 17.
The Panthers got the ball back and Young threw short middle to Jalen Coker. The pass was incomplete, but K.McKinstry was flagged for defensive pass interference, a 30-yard penalty enforced at the Carolina 34. That call was worth 29 points of win probability with 0:28 on the clock. R.Fitzgerald then made a 54-yard field goal as time expired, a 21-point swing, and Carolina won 20-17.
The swing
The Panthers did not win this one on efficiency. Their success rate was 32 percent, two points below New Orleans at 34 percent. They converted 4 of 14 third downs, and Young averaged 5.6 yards per pass attempt as a team.
The gap came from what the Saints did with the ball. New Orleans gave it away twice to Carolina's none, and its rushing offense produced minus-0.851 EPA per carry. EPA, or expected points added, measures how much each play raises or lowers a team's expected score on the drive. The Panthers' rushing figure was plus-0.029 per carry, and they gained 3.0 yards per attempt to the Saints' 2.1. Over 65 plays, Carolina posted minus-0.104 EPA per play against minus-0.333 for New Orleans on 61.
The Panthers also went 2 for 3 on fourth down, against 1 for 3 for the Saints. Their longest drive was six plays for 68 yards and a touchdown. New Orleans' longest went nine plays for 70 yards and a touchdown.
Who moved the needle
Hubbard was the best player in the game by EPA twice over. As a receiver, Hubbard added 5.5 EPA on five plays and finished with five catches for 80 yards, a 16.0 average. As a runner, Hubbard added 3.1 EPA on 27 carries for 92 yards and two touchdowns, a 3.4 average with a long of 17.
Tommy Tremble had four catches for 48 yards and 2.3 EPA on five plays. Tetairoa McMillan caught three of seven targets for 35 yards, and Darren Waller caught two for 24.
Young's line was 17 of 30 for 200 yards with no touchdowns and no interceptions, a 77.1 passer rating. Young was sacked three times for 14 yards and carries minus-7.6 EPA over 34 plays, the worst mark on the team. Coker's four plays came to minus-6.2 EPA.
On defense, Jaelan Phillips had three tackles for loss, a sack and two quarterback hits. Derrick Brown added a sack and a tackle for loss. Devin Lloyd led with nine tackles and a pass defensed, and Tyrel Dodson had seven tackles. Both teams were sacked three times.
Where it leaves them
The record is 4-5 with a one-game winning streak. That is enough for first place in the NFC South, where Tampa Bay and New Orleans are 3-6 and Atlanta is 3-7, and for the fourth seed in the conference.
The margins stay thin. Carolina has scored 219 points and allowed 236, a differential of minus-17. The Panthers are 3-2 on the road and 1-3 at home.
The home record is the next test. Carolina hosts the Baltimore Ravens in Week 11 on Sunday, Nov. 22, at 1:00 PM ET on Fox. It is the Panthers' fifth home game of the season.