Saints played like a team that wins 12% of the time, and Panthers earned it
The snaps gave New Orleans a 12% chance in the 20-17 loss to Carolina, and a 54-yard kick with two seconds left only made the score honest.


The verdict
The snaps gave the Saints a 12% chance against the Carolina Panthers. Played like that, they win about one game in that spot, and Sunday was not the one. The Panthers' 20-17 win was earned.
The deserved margin was Panthers by 6.4 points. The final margin was three. If anything, the scoreboard was kinder to New Orleans than the film.
What the score hid
The Saints averaged -0.20 EPA per snap. EPA, expected points added, measures how many points a play adds or costs compared with what the situation was worth before the snap. Carolina averaged -0.07. Neither offense was good, but the Saints were worse by 0.13 on every snap.
Success rate was 34% for both teams, so the gap came from what the failures cost and what the few good plays returned, not from one side staying on schedule. The luck ledger for the game ran against New Orleans too: -1.4 luck points for the Saints, 0.5 for the Panthers.
The swing play was the last one. R.Fitzgerald's 54-yard field goal with 0:02 left in the fourth quarter added 29 percentage points of win probability for Carolina. It came after a 30-yard defensive pass interference flag on the Saints at 0:28, worth 20 points of win probability by itself.
The calls
The officials did not decide this game against New Orleans. Three flags on Carolina helped the Saints: unnecessary roughness in the third quarter (7 points of win probability), then defensive pass interference at 4:40 of the fourth (10) and a face mask at 1:10 (13). The Saints were handed 15, 17 and 15 yards and still lost.
Head coach Kellen Moore made seven graded fourth-down decisions. He went on three and converted one, a third-quarter fourth-and-1 from the Carolina 45. The two stops, a fourth-and-1 in the first quarter and a fourth-and-1 from the 25 in the second, matched the model's call.
The two punts against the model were small. On fourth-and-2 from his own 11 in the first quarter, Moore punted where the model leaned toward going, a cost of 0.4 expected points. The fourth-and-5 punt at 11:44 of the fourth was a tossup. That is not where this game was lost, but it fits a pattern that is still costing him.
The trend
New Orleans is 3-6 and has three deserved wins, so the record is honest. The Saints have no luck wins, no games robbed and a 3-4 mark in one-score games. They rank 15th of 32 in luck wins and 24th in net EPA per snap at -0.076.
Total luck sits at -13.2 points, with -2.7 from fumble recoveries and -3.7 from opponent kicking. Fitzgerald's kick adds to that second column. Those are the categories most likely to move back toward even.
The Chicken Index is the steadier problem. Moore has gone on 5 of the 10 fourth downs where the model recommended going, a 50% rate that ranks 12th most timid of 32. Across 45 graded fourth downs, the Saints have lost 4.6 expected points, with two clear misses.
Next up is a Week 11 road game at the Chicago Bears, Sunday, Nov. 22 at 1:00 PM ET on Fox.