Pigskin Nightly
More
Week 11
Latest
IND 3FinalHOU 26ARI SunKC BAL SunCAR MIA SunBUF NO SunCHI TB SunDET TEN SunDAL PIT SunPHI NYJ SunLAC JAX SunNYG LV SunDEN MIN SunSF CIN MonWSH
2026 season · box score + nflverse play-by-play

Compare players

Player one
J.J. McCarthyQB · NYG
Player two
Joe MiltonQB · PHI
Compare →
Lineup · up to 4
J.J. McCarthyQB · NYGJoe MiltonQB · PHI
Span
Choose
Metrics22/22
Usage
Passing
Rushing
J.J. McCarthy
Giants logoNew York Giants

J.J. McCarthy

QBpos#18jersey23age6'3"height219lbs3seasons

Michigan · 2024 draft, round 1, pick 10

VS7of 8 shown metrics led1
Joe Milton
Eagles logoPhiladelphia Eagles

Joe Milton

QBpos#14jersey26age6'5"height236lbs3seasons

Tennessee · 2024 draft, round 6, pick 193

Across the 8 shown metrics with numbers for at least two players (2026 season): McCarthy leads in 7 and Milton leads in 1. A count of who is ahead, not a verdict: the metrics overlap and do not weigh the same.

Usage

McCarthyMilton
+9.8Total EPA-10.8

Passing

McCarthyMilton
915Pass yards169
2Touchdowns0
2Interceptions · lower is better0
+0.129EPA per dropback-0.238
+3.3CPOE · completion % over expected-12.0
8.5%Sack rate · lower is better15.2%

Rushing

McCarthyMilton
85Rush yards64
Advanced metrics14 more · tap to open

Usage

5Games with stats1
61.8%Snap share · average share of team snaps in the games he played100.0%
124Plays with EPA50

Passing

63.5%Completion %52.9%
8.8Yards per attempt5.0
41.9%Success rate23.9%
10.3aDOT · average depth of target8.0

Rushing

15Carries · official rush attempts9
7Designed runs in EPA · QB scrambles count as dropbacks, kneels are left out4
5.7Yards per carry7.1
0Rush TD0
14.3%Success rate50.0%

Advanced rows are not part of the “metrics led” count. Pick exactly what you want under “Choose”.

Total EPA by week (bars) and running total (lines)J.J. McCarthyJoe Milton
●Wk 5●Wk 6●Wk 7Wk 8●Wk 9●Wk 10

Expected points added across every role (passing, rushing, receiving) in the nflverse play-by-play model, in the period you picked. Lines run the total; a missing bar is a week without plays. The dot marks the best week among the 2 players.

Matchups to start with

top passers · most targeted

Box score totals from ESPN (regular season and playoffs; “last 4” is each player's four most recent games with a box score line). EPA, success rate, CPOE, aDOT, target and air-yard share from the nflverse play-by-play over the same games; snap share from nflverse snap counts. EPA per dropback includes sacks and scrambles. Carries are the official ESPN rush attempts; EPA per designed run leaves out quarterback scrambles (they count as dropbacks) and kneel-downs, so for a quarterback the two counts differ. Per opportunity divides counting stats by nflverse dropbacks (passing), ESPN targets (receiving) and ESPN carries (rushing); other counts go per game. Percentiles rank each value among players at the same position with enough volume in the same period (the same groups as the player cards: QBs 12 dropbacks a week, RBs 4.5 carries, wide receivers 2.5 targets, tight ends 2, defenders half the games; fewer than 8 peers, no percentile). The bars compare the players on the page only, not the league.