Pigskin Nightly
More
7 live
Latest
IND 3FinalHOU 26ARI 0Q1 14:28KC 0Win probKC 90%BAL 0Q1 14:55CAR 0Win probCAR 67%MIA 0Q1 14:24BUF 0Win probBUF 96%NO 0Q1 14:33CHI 0Win probCHI 80%TB 0Q1 15:00DET 0TEN 0Q1 14:28DAL 0PIT 0Q1 14:54PHI 0Win probPIT 66%NYJ SunLAC JAX SunNYG LV SunDEN MIN SunSF CIN MonWSH
2026 season · box score + nflverse play-by-play

Compare players

Player one
Anthony Richardson Sr.QB · IND
Player two
J.J. McCarthyQB · NYG
Compare →
Lineup · up to 4
Anthony Richardson Sr.QB · INDJ.J. McCarthyQB · NYG
Span
Choose
Metrics22/22
Usage
Passing
Rushing
Anthony Richardson Sr.
Colts logoIndianapolis Colts

Anthony Richardson Sr.

QBpos#5jersey24age6'4"height244lbs4seasons

Florida · 2023 draft, round 1, pick 4

VS1of 8 shown metrics led7
J.J. McCarthy
Giants logoNew York Giants

J.J. McCarthy

QBpos#18jersey23age6'3"height219lbs3seasons

Michigan · 2024 draft, round 1, pick 10

Across the 8 shown metrics with numbers for at least two players (2026 season): McCarthy leads in 7 and Richardson Sr. leads in 1. A count of who is ahead, not a verdict: the metrics overlap and do not weigh the same.

Usage

Richardson Sr.McCarthy
-5.9Total EPA+9.8

Passing

Richardson Sr.McCarthy
8Pass yards915
0Touchdowns2
0Interceptions · lower is better2
-0.937EPA per dropback+0.129
-14.8CPOE · completion % over expected+3.3
16.7%Sack rate · lower is better8.5%

Rushing

Richardson Sr.McCarthy
6Rush yards85
Advanced metrics14 more · tap to open

Usage

2Games with stats5
13.5%Snap share · average share of team snaps in the games he played61.8%
7Plays with EPA124

Passing

50.0%Completion %63.5%
2.0Yards per attempt8.8
0.0%Success rate41.9%
13.3aDOT · average depth of target10.3

Rushing

3Carries · official rush attempts15
1Designed runs in EPA · QB scrambles count as dropbacks, kneels are left out7
2.0Yards per carry5.7
0Rush TD0
0.0%Success rate14.3%

Advanced rows are not part of the “metrics led” count. Pick exactly what you want under “Choose”.

Total EPA by week (bars) and running total (lines)Anthony Richardson Sr.J.J. McCarthy
●Wk 5●Wk 6●Wk 7●Wk 8●Wk 9●Wk 10●Wk 11

Expected points added across every role (passing, rushing, receiving) in the nflverse play-by-play model, in the period you picked. Lines run the total; a missing bar is a week without plays. The dot marks the best week among the 2 players.

Matchups to start with

top passers · most targeted

Box score totals from ESPN (regular season and playoffs; “last 4” is each player's four most recent games with a box score line). EPA, success rate, CPOE, aDOT, target and air-yard share from the nflverse play-by-play over the same games; snap share from nflverse snap counts. EPA per dropback includes sacks and scrambles. Carries are the official ESPN rush attempts; EPA per designed run leaves out quarterback scrambles (they count as dropbacks) and kneel-downs, so for a quarterback the two counts differ. Per opportunity divides counting stats by nflverse dropbacks (passing), ESPN targets (receiving) and ESPN carries (rushing); other counts go per game. Percentiles rank each value among players at the same position with enough volume in the same period (the same groups as the player cards: QBs 12 dropbacks a week, RBs 4.5 carries, wide receivers 2.5 targets, tight ends 2, defenders half the games; fewer than 8 peers, no percentile). The bars compare the players on the page only, not the league.